Chapter 8 - Court Service

Bangladesh Judiciary Court Structure (Part-1)

The court structure in Bangladesh 

bangladesh-judiciary supreme court.jpg

Figure: The court structure in Bangladesh

Supreme Court

The apex court of the country consisting of two divisions i.e. the Appellate Division and the High Court Division. Chief Justice of Bangladesh and other judges in each division constitute the Supreme Court. Chief justice and other judges are independent in the exercise of their judicial functions subject to the provisions of the Constitution. The Chief Justice and other judges are appointed by the President in accordance with the advice of the Prime Minister. Judges of the Supreme Court are appointed from amongst the advocates of the Supreme Court and judicial officers. Judges appointed in the Appellate Division sit in that division with the Chief Justice, and the judges appointed in the High Court Division sit in that division.

Supreme court.png

Figure : Supreme courts 2 division 

The high court division has the power of judicial review. On the application of any aggrieved person, the high court division may give such directions or orders to any person or authority including a person performing any function in connection with the affairs of the Republic for the enforcement of any of the fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution. In enforcing the fundamental rights, the high court division is empowered to declare any law inconsistent with the fundamental right or any other part of the Constitution void to the extent of the inconsistency. High court division has also original jurisdiction in cases relating to the company, admiralty, matrimonial issues, trademarks, copyrights, etc. The high court division may also withdraw a case from any subordinate court and dispose of the same if any substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution or a point of general public importance is involved in that case.

The high court division has appellate and revisional jurisdictions conferred on it by the laws. An appeal lies to the appellate division as of right from judgment, decree, order, or sentence passed by the high court division where the high court division certifies that the case involves a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution of Bangladesh or has sentenced a person to death or imprisonment for life or has imposed punishment for contempt of that court.

Subordinate civil judiciary

There are five classes of subordinate civil courts i.e. the courts of assistant judges, senior assistant judges, joint district judges, additional district judges, and district judges. The district judge is the head of the judiciary in each of the districts. In the hill districts where there were no separate civil courts, the magistrates performed the functions of the civil courts. But recently civil courts have been sitting there and functioning. Subject to the superintendence of the high court division, the district judge has administrative control over all the civil courts of the district. District judge has mainly appellate as well as revisional jurisdiction, but in some matters, he has original jurisdiction too. The jurisdiction of the additional judge is co-extensive with that of the district judge. He/she discharges the judicial business assigned to him/her by the district judge. Appeals to the judgments, decrees, and orders passed by the assistant judges and subordinate judges lie to the district judge. Similarly, a district judges may transfer the appeals preferred against judgments, decree, or orders passed by the assistant judges to the joint district judges for disposal. Joint district judges have unlimited civil original jurisdiction.

Subordicate Civil judiciary class.png

Figure: Subordinate civil judiciary class

Civil courts while deciding any question regarding succession, inheritance, marriage or caste or any religious usage or institution apply the Muslim law in cases where the parties are Muslims and' Hindu law in cases where the parties are Hindus except so far as such law has been altered or abolished by any enactment made by the legislature.

Artha Rin Adalat (Loan Court) has been set up in each district under the provisions of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain 1990 by the government appointing subordinate judges as judges of such courts in consultation with the supreme court. All suits for realization of the loan of the financial institutions eg bank, investment corporation, house building finance corporation, leasing company, etc and non-banking financial institutions constituted under the provisions of Financial Institutions Act 1993, are to be filed in the Artha Rin Adalats, and such suits are exclusively triable by such courts. Artha Rin Adalat is a civil court and has all the powers of the civil court.

Delia Adalat (Bankruptcy Court) has been constituted under the Bankruptcy Act, 1997. District court in each district is the Bankruptcy court of that district, and district judge is the presiding judge of that court and is authorized to deal with and dispose of bankruptcy cases arising within the district and he/she may authorize an additional (district) judge to deal with and dispose of any such case.

Assistant judges, senior assistant judges as well as joint district judges have been empowered with the functions of Courts of Small Cause to entertain and try suits for the realization of money up to thirty thousand takas and for ejectment of the monthly tenant by the landlord when twelve months' rent of the premises is equivalent to the above amount. No appeal lies from the decree or most of the orders passed by the Court of Small Cause except appeal to the district judge from certain orders. But a revision may be filed to the High Court Division by an aggrieved party against the decree or non-appealable order. Assistant judges and senior assistant judges also perform the functions of the Rent Controller deciding disputes between the landlords and monthly tenants of house premises other than suits for the realization of arrear of rent or ejectment from the rented premises such as deposit of rent by the tenant on the refusal of the landlord to accept the same, repair of the premises, fixation of standard rent, etc. Assistant judges and senior assistant judges also constitute Family Courts to entertain and try suits arising from family disputes such as restitution of conjugal rights, dissolution of marriage, maintenance of wife and children, custody of children, etc.

 

 

Bangladesh Judiciary Court Structure (Part-2)

The court structure in Bangladesh 

bangladesh-judiciary supreme court.jpg

Figure: The court structure in Bangladesh

Subordinate criminal courts

There are several classes of subordinate criminal courts. These are courts of session, courts of judicial magistrates, and courts of metropolitan magistrates. Courts of judicial magistrates include the chief judicial magistrate, additional chief judicial magistrate, and judicial magistrates of the first, second, and third class. Courts of metropolitan magistrates include the courts of the chief metropolitan magistrate, additional chief metropolitan magistrate, and other metropolitan magistrates all exercising power of first-class judicial magistrate. Divisional Commissioner transformed the functions of the court of session for the three hill districts, but since 2008 courts of sessions have been set up in the hill districts. Since January 1999 metropolitan courts of session have been established for the Dhaka and Chittagong metropolitan areas. For performing functions other than judicial there are executive magistrates.

Criminal court.png

Figure: Criman court class

District judges have been empowered to function as sessions judges, additional district judges as additional sessions judges and joint district judges as joint sessions judges in the districts. In every district, the district judge performs the functions of the sessions judge; additional district judge or judges those of the additional sessions judge or judges and joint district judges those of the joint sessions judges.

Metropolitan session courts have been constituted with former district judges as the metropolitan sessions judges, former additional district judges as metropolitan additional sessions judges and former joint district judges as metropolitan joint sessions judges in those metropolitan areas. Joint sessions judges are subordinate to the sessions judges and sessions judges may make rules for the distribution of business to joint sessions judges. Though additional sessions judges exercise the same power as exercised by the sessions judges business may be distributed by the sessions judge of the district to the additional sessions judge or judges in that district.

Judges of the courts of the session also function as special judges under the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 1958 to try offences under the provisions of Prevention of Corruption Act 1947, and now repealed Anti-Corruption Act 1957 replaced at present by the Durniti Daman Commission Ain 2004. Judges of the courts of the session also act as special tribunals to try offences under the provisions of the Special Powers Act 1974. Sessions judge, additional sessions judge or joint sessions judge acting as the special tribunal may award any sentence authorised by law. Sessions judges and additional session judges also act as Special Courts for suppression of repression of women and children under the provisions of the Suppression of Repression of Women and Children (Special Provisions) Act 2000.

Sessions judges also act as Public Safety Tribunals under the Public Safety (Special Provisions) Act, 2000 for trying offences under that Act. By the Public Safety (Special Provisions) (Amendment) Act, 2002 most of the provisions of the said Act has been repealed but provided for the continuation of the pending cases under the said Act reserving power in the government to withdraw appropriate cases. Those repealed provisions have been re-enacted in slightly modified form by the Law and Order Disruptive Crimes (Speedy Trial) Act 2002, and metropolitan magistrates and judicial magistrates of the first class have been empowered to try such offences within a very short time as Speedy Trial Courts.

Administrative tribunals

Administrative tribunals have been established by the government and each of the tribunals consists of one member appointed by the government from amongst persons who are or have been district judges. The administrative tribunal has exclusive jurisdiction to hear and determine applications made by any person in the service of the Republic (excluding a person in the defence service) or specified bodies and organisations such as Bangladesh Bank etc in respect of terms and conditions of his service including pension rights or any action taken in relation to him as a person in such service. An appeal lies from the decision of the administrative tribunal to the administrative appellate tribunal consisting of a chairman and two members. The chairman shall be a person who is, or has been, or is qualified to be a judge of the Supreme Court or is or has been an officer in the service of the Republic not below the rank of additional secretary to the government. The government appoints a retired judge of the Supreme Court as chairman. One of the members is appointed from amongst the retired or serving district judges and another from amongst the retired or serving joint secretaries of the government. Appeal from the decision of the administrative appellate tribunal lies to the appellate division of the Supreme Court with leave of that division.

Labour Courts have been established to adjudicate disputes regarding the employment of commercial or industrial labour. Each of the Labour Courts consists of a chairman and two members. The chairman is appointed from amongst the district judges or additional district judges and one of the members is appointed in consultation with the employers and the other in consultation with the workmen. Labour Court adjudicates and decides industrial disputes, implementation or violation of settlements, and complaints made between the employers and workers and complaints made by workers in respect of retrenchment, lay off, termination and dismissal from service, nonpayment of wages or compensation for disablement in course of service, and it also tries offences in respect of unfair labour practices, breach of or failure to implement the settlement, illegal strike or lock-out and non-compliance of Labour Court's order. Any party aggrieved by an award of the Labour Court may prefer an appeal to the Labour Appellate Tribunal. Such tribunal consists of one member only appointed by the government from amongst the sitting or retired judges of the Supreme Court. Labour appellate tribunal is required to dispose of an appeal against an award of the Labour Court in respect of any labour dispute as the reinstatement of any worker or workers in service within 180 days of filing the same. But no appeal lies from the decision of the labour court. If any party feels aggrieved by the decision of the labour court he may file an application before the High Court Division for issuing a writ of certiorari to examine the record of the case to satisfy itself as to the legality or propriety of the same. The decision of the labour court as commissioner of workmen's compensation is appealable to the High Court Division.

Court of Settlement

Following the liberation of Bangladesh, the government promulgated Abandoned Property (Control, Management and Disposal) Order 1972 (President's Order No.16 of 1972) and made provisions for taking over control, management and disposal of properties that fell within the definition of abandoned property. Disputes arose about the decision of the government in respect of such properties and to set at rest such disputes forever the government made provisions under the Abandoned Buildings (Supplementary Provisions) Ordinance 1985 for publishing list of all abandoned buildings in the official gazette and for deciding the claims to such properties by a tribunal called the Court of Settlement. The court of settlement has been constituted by the government with a chairman and two other members. The chairman is appointed from amongst persons who are or have been or are qualified to be a judge or additional judge of the Supreme Court. Of the two members, one is appointed from amongst persons who are or have been judicial officers not below the rank of additional district judge and the other from amongst persons who are or have been officers not below the rank of a deputy secretary of the government. The court of settlement decides the application made to it by any aggrieved person for excluding property from the list of abandoned buildings after hearing the parties and considering the evidence adduced before it. No appeal lies from the decision of the Court of settlement. An aggrieved party may file an application to the High Court Division for issuance of a writ of certiorari to examine the record of the case to satisfy itself as to the legality or propriety of the decision of the court of settlement.

Arbitration and arbitration appellate tribunal

 The government may requisition or acquire any land or building owned by any person for a public purpose or in the public interest and pay compensation to the owner and occupier of such land or building as per the assessment made by the land acquisition officers. Any person aggrieved by an order of assessment of compensation may file an application to the Arbitrator appointed by the government from amongst persons holding post,s not below the rank of the joint district judge. An appeal lies to the Arbitration Appellate Tribunal constituted with a member appointed from amongst persons who are or have been district judges against the award of the Arbitrator. The decision of the Arbitration Appellate Tribunal determining the amount of compensation is final. An aggrieved party may file an application to the High Court Division for issuance of a writ of certiorari to examine the record of the case to satisfy itself as to the legality or propriety of the decision of the Arbitration Appellate Tribunal. Generally one of the joint district judges of the district court is appointed as the arbitrator and the district judge of the district as the Arbitration Appellate Tribunal to decide questions of quantum of compensation.

Election tribunals

Election disputes require to be settled by tribunals appointed by the Election Commission which is entrusted with the functions of organizing, holding and conducting the election of members of the Jatiya Sangsad and the mayor or chairmen, commissioners or members of local bodies such as union parishads in the rural areas and pourashavas (municipalities) in the urban areas and city corporations in metropolitan areas. To decide election disputes arising from the election of the members of Jatiya Sangsad the Election Commission previously appointed as many tribunals as found necessary from amongst persons who are or have been district judges. Appeal from the decision of such election dispute lay to the High Court Division. Since 2001 a judge of the High Court Division performs the function of such tribunal to decide such election disputes. Similarly to decide election disputes arising from the election of mayor or chairman and commissioners/members of the municipalities or union parishads and city corporations, Election Commission appoints judicial officers as Election Tribunals. Appeal from the decision of such election dispute lies to the district judge of the district in which such tribunal is situated. Revision lies to the High Court Division against the decision of the district judge made in an appeal from the decision of the Election Tribunal. A judicial officer of the rank of a district judge or the district judge of each district was appointed Election Tribunal prior to 2001 for adjudication of election disputes arising from the election of members of Jatiya Sangsad. But assistant judges are appointed Election Tribunals to decide election disputes arising from the election of chairman and members of the union parishads. Similarly, joint district judges have appointed Election Tribunals for deciding the disputes arising from the election of the mayor and ward commissioners of the municipalities and the city corporations.

 

Bangladesh Judiciary Court Structure (Part-3)

Vested property return tribunal and appellate tribunal

Under the provision of the Vested Property Return Act, 2001 the government shall by notification in the official gazette appoint ordinarily one tribunal for each district or if necessary one tribunal for more than one district or additional tribunal for any one district to be known as Vested Property Return Tribunal. Tribunal shall be constituted with a judicial officer of the rank of a district judge or additional district judge and the government may appoint a judge of such tribunal or additional tribunal to act solely or in addition to his ordinary duties as such tribunal. In case of necessity, the government may appoint on contract basis a retired district judge not exceeding sixty years of age to act solely as such tribunal. The said law provides for preparation and publication by gazette notification a list of returnable vested properties within 180 days of coming into force of the Act and for the owner of such property for filing an application to the tribunal within ninety days of publication of such list for return of such property to him and the tribunal to deliver judgment within 180 days of receipt of such an application. The law also provides for preferring the appeal within 45 days of the judgment or decision of the tribunal against the same to the appellate tribunal. The law also provides for the constitution of one or more appellate tribunals to be known as Vested Property Return Appellate Tribunal by the government and in case of the constitution of more than one appellate tribunals to determine their respective territorial jurisdiction. In consultation with the Chief Justice of Bangladesh, the government shall appoint a judge of the appellate tribunal from amongst persons eligible to be the judge of the Supreme Court or a retired judge of the Supreme Court whose tenure shall expire on completion of sixty-seven years of his age. The appellate tribunal shall sit in the capital of the country and in case of the constitution of more than one appellate tribunals at the places directed by the government. The appellate tribunal shall pass its judgment within 180 days of the filing the appeal. A further appeal shall lie against the judgment of the appellate tribunal to the appellate division of the Supreme Court on a specific question of law with leave of that division.

Land survey tribunal and appellate tribunal 

Under the provisions of the State Acquisition and Tenancy (Amendment), Act 2004 government may, by notification in the official gazette, establish as many Land Survey Tribunals as may be required to dispose of the suits arising out of the final publication of the last revised record of rights prepared under section 144 of the said Act. The government may, by notification in the official gazette, fix and alter the territorial limits of the jurisdiction of any land survey tribunal. Government shall, in consultation with the Supreme Court, appoint the judge of the land survey tribunal from among persons who are joint district judges. An appeal arising out of judgment, decree, or order of the land survey tribunal shall lie to the land survey appellate tribunal established by the government by notification in the official gazette. More than one such appellate tribunals may be established to hear such appeals. The government may, by notification in the official gazette, fix and alter the territorial limits of the jurisdiction of any land survey appellate tribunal. Government shall appoint the judge of the land survey appellate tribunal from among persons who are or have been judges of the high court division of the Supreme Court. An appeal from a judgment or order of the land survey appellate tribunal shall lie to the appellate division of the Supreme Court only if the appellate division grants leave to appeal.

Other Tibunals and Special courts